Files
ComfyAssets-ComfyUI_PromptM…/tests/test_review_outcome.py
T
Vito Sansevero 18d81c9d96 fix(review): never queue an ambiguous file with nothing to choose
The maintainer's live queue held 39 items whose candidates all read
"unresolved" ("No positive / No negative"). An ambiguous result is now
reviewable only when at least two candidates are resolved with non-blank
positive text. With none the file could not be traced; with exactly one,
the untraced branches may still have made the file, so that text is not
certain either. Both are reported unresolved, never linked and never
queued (also the A1111 two-delimiter case, which has no candidates).

A rescan removes the pending items of such files whose own evidence
offers no choice, with the same safe delete as the linked settle
(pending, revision 0, no decision row). A limited item (over 16 candidates) that holds at least two
candidates is kept. The job scope gains review_untraced and the log
"= N images left Needs review · nothing to choose".
2026-10-23 13:03:10 -07:00

375 lines
14 KiB
Python

"""Needs review takes only files whose final outcome is ambiguous and unlinked.
The maintainer's live scan (#284 / #288) queued every file the strict
resolver found ambiguous, also those the legacy browser-parser fallback then
linked and those already linked, so the queue (10,232) was far larger than
the scan's Needs review group. The rule now: a file is queued only when the
resolver finds it ambiguous, the fallback does not link it and no saved row
links it. A pending, undecided item whose file is linked (by the fallback, a
later resolution or the monitor) is removed on the next scan or monitor
pass; an item that carries a decision is never touched.
"""
import json
import logging
import os
import sqlite3
import unittest
from unittest.mock import patch
try:
from tests.test_review import (
DELIMITERS,
NOW,
ReviewTestCase,
ambiguous_graph,
resolved_graph,
unlinkable_graph,
write_png,
)
except ImportError: # discovered with tests/ as the top-level directory
from test_review import (
DELIMITERS,
NOW,
ReviewTestCase,
ambiguous_graph,
resolved_graph,
unlinkable_graph,
write_png,
)
from utils.hashing import generate_prompt_hash
from utils.image_monitor import ImageGenerationHandler
from utils.prompt_tracker import PromptTracker
from utils import review_capture
def nan_stamped(graph):
"""ComfyUI's ``is_changed: [NaN]`` stamp (written as a bare NaN literal)."""
for node in graph.values():
node["is_changed"] = [float("nan")]
return graph
class OutcomeTestCase(ReviewTestCase):
def _pending(self):
return self.api.db.library_counts()["review_pending"]
def _record(self, name):
"""An item as the pre-fix producers recorded it (any ambiguous file)."""
outcome = review_capture.record_ambiguous_file(
self.api.db, self.api._captures, self.output_dir, 0, name
)
self.assertIn(outcome, ("recorded", "limited"))
def _decide(self, item, outcome):
conn = self.api.db.model.get_connection()
candidate = None
if outcome == "selected":
candidate = json.loads(item["evidence"])["candidates"][0]["hash"]
with conn:
conn.execute(
"UPDATE media_review_items SET state=?, revision=1 WHERE id=?",
(outcome, item["id"]),
)
conn.execute(
"INSERT INTO media_review_decisions(id,item_id,decision_revision,"
"created_at,outcome,candidate_hash,evidence) VALUES(?,?,?,?,?,?,?)",
(
f"00000000-0000-4000-8000-{len(self._decisions()) + 1:012d}",
item["id"],
1,
NOW,
outcome,
candidate,
'{"kind":"user-selection"}',
),
)
def _decisions(self):
conn = self.api.db.model.get_connection()
return [
tuple(row)
for row in conn.execute(
"SELECT id,item_id,outcome FROM media_review_decisions ORDER BY id"
)
]
def _link(self, path, text="already saved"):
prompt_id = self.api.db.save_prompt(
text=text, prompt_hash=generate_prompt_hash(text)
)
self.api.db.link_image_to_prompt(prompt_id, str(path))
return prompt_id
@staticmethod
def _rows(job, group):
return sorted(row["path"] for row in job["outcomes"].get(group, []))
class TestOnlyUnlinkedAmbiguousFilesAreQueued(OutcomeTestCase):
async def test_nan_stamped_graph_the_fallback_links_is_not_queued(self):
self._roots()
path = self.output_dir / "nan.png"
write_png(path, prompt=nan_stamped(ambiguous_graph("cat", "dog")))
self.assertIn(b"NaN", path.read_bytes())
job = await self._scan()
self.assertEqual(job["counters"]["added"], 1, job["counters"])
self.assertEqual(self._items(), [])
self.assertEqual(job["scope"]["review_items"], 0)
self.assertEqual(self._pending(), 0)
async def test_fallback_link_to_a_known_prompt_is_not_queued(self):
self._roots()
write_png(self.output_dir / "a.png", prompt=ambiguous_graph("cat", "dog"))
await self._scan()
write_png(self.output_dir / "b.png", prompt=ambiguous_graph("cat", "dog"))
job = await self._scan()
self.assertEqual(self._items(), [])
self.assertEqual(job["scope"]["review_items"], 0)
async def test_already_linked_file_is_not_queued(self):
self._roots()
path = self.output_dir / "linked.png"
write_png(path, prompt=unlinkable_graph("cat", "dog"))
self._link(path)
job = await self._scan()
self.assertEqual(self._items(), [])
self.assertEqual(job["scope"]["review_items"], 0)
self.assertEqual(self._rows(job, "review"), [])
self.assertEqual(self._rows(job, "known"), ["linked.png"])
async def test_genuinely_ambiguous_file_is_queued(self):
self._roots()
path = self.output_dir / "two.png"
write_png(path, prompt=nan_stamped(unlinkable_graph("cat", "dog")))
# Beside it, a file the fallback links: only the first is queued.
write_png(self.output_dir / "linked.png", prompt=ambiguous_graph("a", "b"))
job = await self._scan()
(item,) = self._items()
self.assertEqual(os.path.basename(item["locator"]), "two.png")
self.assertEqual(item["state"], "pending")
self.assertEqual(item["candidate_count"], 3)
self.assertEqual(job["scope"]["review_items"], 1)
self.assertEqual(self._rows(job, "review"), ["two.png"])
self.assertEqual(self._pending(), 1)
self.assertIn("? 1 image added to Needs review", "\n".join(job["log"]))
async def test_counter_and_queue_agree_with_the_review_group(self):
"""``review_items`` and the queue total equal the review group less
its unresolved files, on the first scan and on a rescan."""
self._roots()
for name in ("u1.png", "u2.png"):
write_png(self.output_dir / name, prompt=unlinkable_graph("cat", name))
write_png(self.output_dir / "delims.png", parameters=DELIMITERS)
write_png(self.output_dir / "linked.png", prompt=ambiguous_graph("a", "b"))
unresolved = {"1": {"class_type": "KSampler", "inputs": {}}}
write_png(self.output_dir / "none.png", prompt=unresolved)
write_png(self.output_dir / "one.png", prompt=resolved_graph())
for _ in range(2):
job = await self._scan()
review = self._rows(job, "review")
unresolved_rows = sorted(
row["path"]
for row in job["outcomes"]["review"]
if "could not be traced" in row["detail"]
)
queued = [name for name in review if name not in unresolved_rows]
# delims.png has nothing to choose: "could not be traced".
self.assertEqual(queued, ["u1.png", "u2.png"], job)
self.assertIn("delims.png", unresolved_rows)
self.assertEqual(job["scope"]["review_items"], 2)
self.assertEqual(self._pending(), 2)
self.assertIn("? 2 images already in Needs review", "\n".join(job["log"]))
class TestQueueSelfHeals(OutcomeTestCase):
async def test_pending_item_of_a_fallback_linked_file_is_removed(self):
"""The maintainer's case: queued by the old rule, linked on rescan."""
self._roots()
path = self.output_dir / "nan.png"
write_png(path, prompt=nan_stamped(ambiguous_graph("cat", "dog")))
self._record("nan.png")
revision = self._review_revision()
self.assertEqual(self._pending(), 1)
job = await self._scan()
self.assertEqual(self._items(), [])
self.assertEqual(self._pending(), 0)
self.assertGreater(self._review_revision(), revision)
self.assertEqual(job["scope"]["review_settled"], 1)
self.assertIn("= 1 image left Needs review · now linked", "\n".join(job["log"]))
async def test_pending_item_of_an_already_linked_file_is_removed(self):
self._roots()
path = self.output_dir / "linked.png"
write_png(path, prompt=unlinkable_graph("cat", "dog"))
self._record("linked.png")
self._link(path)
await self._scan()
self.assertEqual(self._items(), [])
self.assertEqual(self._pending(), 0)
async def test_pending_item_of_a_skipped_known_file_is_removed(self):
"""A file the "new" scope skips as known still settles its old item."""
self._roots()
path = self.output_dir / "one.png"
write_png(path, prompt=unlinkable_graph("cat", "dog"))
self._record("one.png")
write_png(path, prompt=resolved_graph())
first = await self._scan()
self.assertEqual(self._rows(first, "added"), ["one.png"])
# An item a pre-fix scan left for the file's old bytes.
self.assertEqual(self._items(), [])
write_png(path, prompt=unlinkable_graph("cat", "dog"), color=(0, 9, 0))
self._record("one.png")
write_png(path, prompt=resolved_graph())
second = await self._scan()
self.assertEqual(self._rows(second, "known"), ["one.png"])
self.assertEqual(self._items(), [])
async def test_a_failed_settle_is_logged_and_counted_not_fatal(self):
self._roots()
write_png(self.output_dir / "nan.png", prompt=ambiguous_graph("cat", "dog"))
self._record("nan.png")
with (
patch.object(
self.api.db,
"settle_linked_review_items",
side_effect=sqlite3.OperationalError("database is locked"),
),
self.assertLogs("prompt_manager.api", logging.WARNING) as logs,
):
job = await self._scan()
self.assertEqual(job["state"], "finished")
self.assertEqual(job["scope"]["review_errors"], 1)
self.assertEqual(job["scope"]["review_settled"], 0)
self.assertTrue(any("could not be removed" in line for line in logs.output))
self.assertEqual(self._pending(), 1)
# The next scan settles it.
await self._scan()
self.assertEqual(self._pending(), 0)
async def test_still_unlinked_pending_item_stays(self):
self._roots()
write_png(self.output_dir / "two.png", prompt=unlinkable_graph("cat", "dog"))
await self._scan()
(item,) = self._items()
job = await self._scan()
self.assertEqual([i["id"] for i in self._items()], [item["id"]])
self.assertEqual(job["scope"].get("review_settled", 0), 0)
async def test_decided_items_are_never_touched(self):
self._roots()
for name in ("sel.png", "unres.png"):
write_png(self.output_dir / name, prompt=ambiguous_graph("cat", name))
self._record(name)
items = {os.path.basename(i["locator"]): i for i in self._items()}
self._decide(items["sel.png"], "selected")
self._decide(items["unres.png"], "unresolved")
before = (self._items(), self._decisions())
# A pending neighbour the fallback links: it alone leaves the queue.
write_png(self.output_dir / "pending.png", prompt=ambiguous_graph("x", "y"))
self._record("pending.png")
self.assertEqual(self._pending(), 1)
job = await self._scan("all")
self.assertEqual((self._items(), self._decisions()), before)
self.assertEqual(self._pending(), 0)
self.assertEqual(job["scope"]["review_settled"], 1)
class TestMonitorRule(OutcomeTestCase):
def _handler(self):
handler = ImageGenerationHandler(self.api.db, PromptTracker(self.api.db))
handler.review_recorder = self.api.record_review_file
return handler
def _context(self):
prompt_id = self.api.db.save_prompt(
text="latest", prompt_hash=generate_prompt_hash("latest")
)
return {"id": prompt_id, "text": "latest", "fallback": True}
async def test_monitor_linked_ambiguous_output_is_not_queued(self):
self._roots()
path = self.output_dir / "two.png"
graph = unlinkable_graph("cat", "dog")
write_png(path, prompt=graph)
self._handler().link_image_to_prompt(
str(path), self._context(), {"prompt": graph}
)
self.assertEqual(self._items(), [])
async def test_monitor_link_removes_the_files_pending_item(self):
self._roots()
path = self.output_dir / "two.png"
graph = unlinkable_graph("cat", "dog")
write_png(path, prompt=graph)
self._record("two.png")
self.assertEqual(self._pending(), 1)
self._handler().link_image_to_prompt(
str(path), self._context(), {"prompt": graph}
)
self.assertEqual(self._items(), [])
self.assertEqual(self._pending(), 0)
async def test_monitor_never_touches_a_decided_item(self):
self._roots()
path = self.output_dir / "two.png"
graph = unlinkable_graph("cat", "dog")
write_png(path, prompt=graph)
self._record("two.png")
(item,) = self._items()
self._decide(item, "unresolved")
before = (self._items(), self._decisions())
other = self.output_dir / "other.png"
write_png(other, prompt=graph, color=(0, 0, 9))
self._record("other.png")
handler, context = self._handler(), self._context()
handler.link_image_to_prompt(str(path), context, {"prompt": graph})
handler.link_image_to_prompt(str(other), context, {"prompt": graph})
self.assertEqual((self._items(), self._decisions()), before)
self.assertEqual(self._pending(), 0)
async def test_record_review_file_applies_the_scan_rule(self):
self._roots()
write_png(self.output_dir / "fallback.png", prompt=ambiguous_graph("a", "b"))
write_png(self.output_dir / "two.png", prompt=unlinkable_graph("cat", "dog"))
linked = self.output_dir / "linked.png"
write_png(linked, prompt=unlinkable_graph("cat", "dog"))
self._link(linked)
record = self.api.record_review_file
self.assertEqual(record(str(self.output_dir / "fallback.png")), "skipped")
self.assertEqual(record(str(linked)), "linked")
self.assertEqual(record(str(self.output_dir / "two.png")), "recorded")
self.assertEqual(len(self._items()), 1)
if __name__ == "__main__":
unittest.main()