Files
robertvoy-ComfyUI-Distributed/tests/test_transfer_codec.py
T
6edd3fda38 feat(collector): optional compressed worker → master result transfer (#97)
* feat(collector): compressed worker -> master result transfer

Workers sent every frame as an uncompressed PNG (compress_level=0),
base64-encoded inside a JSON request, one request per frame. For cloud
workers this makes result download (egress) the dominant transfer cost:
a 121-frame 720p batch is ~446 MB per worker.

Add `transfer_format` / `transfer_quality` optional widgets to
Distributed Collector:

- legacy_png (default): unchanged behaviour
- png, ffv1: lossless, bit-identical master tensors to legacy_png
- jpeg, webp: lossy stills
- h264, h265, av1: lossy video of the whole batch

Compressed results are posted as multipart/form-data chunks (binary, no
base64, ~32 MB soft cap per request, configurable with
COMFYUI_DISTRIBUTED_TRANSFER_CHUNK_BYTES). The master decodes each chunk
off the event loop and enqueues one item per frame, so collection,
ordering and audio handling are unchanged. Encoding also runs in an
executor on the worker.

Compatibility:
- /distributed/job_complete still accepts the legacy JSON envelope.
- A worker talking to an older master gets a 400 on the first chunk and
  resends everything as legacy_png.
- Missing video encoders fall back to h264 (lossy) or png (ffv1).

Measured on 121 frames at 1280x720: png 163 MB (2.7x), ffv1 128 MB
(3.5x), h264 q90 2.4 MB (186x, 40.2 dB), av1 q90 0.4 MB.

Also clips IMAGE values before 8-bit quantization on the new path so
out-of-range values no longer wrap around.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_0166t8T3CVaxZkJbP2RtSpo6

* fix(collector): wire transfer options through V3 node; bound finalized payload size

Addresses review on #97.

V3 integration
- Add optional `transfer_format` / `transfer_quality` inputs to the
  registered nodes/v3.py DistributedCollector schema (legacy defaults) and
  accept/forward them in execute() to the runtime helper.
- tests/test_v3_collector_transfer.py checks the registered node's public
  schema and argument forwarding without a ComfyUI checkout; the opt-in
  real-runtime acceptance (tests/helpers/v3_runtime_check.py) now allows
  exactly these appended optional inputs, verifies their contract, and
  checks forwarding through the real executor.

Payload size bound
- encode_chunks() enforces limits on finalized bytes (after encoder flush
  and muxer finalization). Encoder lookahead kept the pre-flush buffer
  near zero, so a chunk could hold the whole batch and finalize far above
  the limit. Oversized video chunks are re-encoded with proportionally
  fewer frames; the next chunk is sized from observed bytes/frame.
- Multi-frame chunks stay within TRANSFER_MAX_CHUNK_BYTES (32 MiB); a
  single frame may use up to TRANSFER_MAX_REQUEST_BYTES (96 MiB, new,
  COMFYUI_DISTRIBUTED_TRANSFER_MAX_REQUEST_BYTES) minus envelope reserve.
  A frame that cannot fit raises FrameTooLargeError.
- The worker encodes all chunks before sending, so an unfittable frame
  fails before anything is delivered (no partial batch on the master).
- Audio rides on the last chunk only when the request stays in bounds;
  otherwise it is sent as a final audio-only completion.
- Legacy fallback triggers only on an older master's rejection
  ("Invalid JSON payload"); other errors, e.g. size limits, raise with a
  pointer to the limit settings instead of resending as legacy_png.
- The master returns 413 when a request exceeds --max-upload-size.

Tests: codec flush-overshoot and single-frame cases, worker fallback /
nothing-sent / audio placement, and real aiohttp server tests with
client_max_size covering bounded high-entropy video, 413 reporting, and
unfittable frames.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_0166t8T3CVaxZkJbP2RtSpo6

---------

Co-authored-by: ymiyad <ymiyad@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-10-11 20:50:23 +00:00

220 lines
8.7 KiB
Python

import importlib.util
import io
import sys
from pathlib import Path
import numpy as np
import pytest
import torch
from PIL import Image
def _load_codec():
path = Path(__file__).resolve().parents[1] / "utils" / "transfer_codec.py"
spec = importlib.util.spec_from_file_location("dist_transfer_codec_test", path)
module = importlib.util.module_from_spec(spec)
sys.modules["dist_transfer_codec_test"] = module
spec.loader.exec_module(module)
return module
tc = _load_codec()
def _smooth_frames(count=4, height=67, width=91):
"""Smooth moving gradient, closer to generated content than random noise."""
yy, xx = np.mgrid[0:height, 0:width].astype(np.float32)
frames = []
for i in range(count):
r = 0.5 + 0.5 * np.sin((xx + 3 * i) / 13.0)
g = 0.5 + 0.5 * np.cos((yy - 2 * i) / 11.0)
b = (xx + yy + 5 * i) / (width + height + 5 * count)
frames.append(np.stack([r, g, b], axis=-1))
return torch.from_numpy(np.stack(frames)).float()
def _legacy_master_tensor(frame_tensor):
"""What the unmodified pipeline delivered: tensor_to_pil -> PNG -> pil_to_tensor."""
img = Image.fromarray((255 * frame_tensor.numpy()).astype(np.uint8))
buf = io.BytesIO()
img.save(buf, format="PNG", compress_level=0)
with Image.open(io.BytesIO(buf.getvalue())) as decoded:
return np.array(decoded.convert("RGB")).astype(np.float32) / 255.0
def _round_trip(frames_u8, fmt, quality=90, max_chunk_bytes=10**9):
out = []
chunks = list(tc.encode_chunks(frames_u8, fmt, quality, max_chunk_bytes))
for chunk in chunks:
envelope = {k: v for k, v in chunk.items() if k != "parts"}
out.extend(tc.decode_chunk(envelope, chunk["parts"]))
return chunks, out
def _psnr(a, b):
mse = np.mean((a.astype(np.float64) - b.astype(np.float64)) ** 2)
return float("inf") if mse == 0 else 10 * np.log10(255.0**2 / mse)
@pytest.mark.parametrize("fmt", ["png", "ffv1"])
def test_lossless_formats_reproduce_legacy_master_tensors_exactly(fmt):
images = _smooth_frames()
frames = tc.tensor_batch_to_uint8(images)
_, decoded = _round_trip(frames, fmt)
assert len(decoded) == images.shape[0]
for i, frame in enumerate(decoded):
got = tc.uint8_frame_to_tensor_array(frame)[0]
assert np.array_equal(got, _legacy_master_tensor(images[i]))
@pytest.mark.parametrize("fmt", ["jpeg", "webp", "h264", "h265", "av1"])
def test_lossy_formats_round_trip_odd_sizes_with_reasonable_quality(fmt):
if fmt in tc.VIDEO_FORMATS and not tc.video_codec_available(fmt):
pytest.skip(f"{fmt} encoder not available in this PyAV build")
frames = tc.tensor_batch_to_uint8(_smooth_frames())
_, decoded = _round_trip(frames, fmt, quality=90)
assert len(decoded) == frames.shape[0]
for i, frame in enumerate(decoded):
assert frame.shape == frames[i].shape
assert frame.dtype == np.uint8
assert _psnr(frame, frames[i]) > 30
def test_h265_handles_frames_smaller_than_ctu():
if not tc.video_codec_available("h265"):
pytest.skip("h265 encoder not available")
frames = tc.tensor_batch_to_uint8(_smooth_frames(count=3, height=17, width=23))
_, decoded = _round_trip(frames, "h265")
assert [f.shape for f in decoded] == [(17, 23, 3)] * 3
def test_image_formats_split_chunks_by_byte_cap_and_keep_order():
frames = tc.tensor_batch_to_uint8(_smooth_frames(count=5))
one = len(tc.encode_image_frame(frames[0], "png", 90))
chunks, decoded = _round_trip(frames, "png", max_chunk_bytes=one * 2 + 1)
assert len(chunks) >= 3
assert [c["start_index"] for c in chunks] == sorted(c["start_index"] for c in chunks)
assert sum(c["count"] for c in chunks) == 5
assert all(len(c["parts"]) == c["count"] for c in chunks)
assert np.array_equal(np.stack(decoded), frames)
def test_video_formats_split_chunks_by_frame_cap(monkeypatch):
monkeypatch.setattr(tc, "MAX_VIDEO_CHUNK_FRAMES", 2)
frames = tc.tensor_batch_to_uint8(_smooth_frames(count=5))
chunks, decoded = _round_trip(frames, "ffv1")
assert [(c["start_index"], c["count"]) for c in chunks] == [(0, 2), (2, 2), (4, 1)]
assert all(len(c["parts"]) == 1 for c in chunks)
assert np.array_equal(np.stack(decoded), frames)
def test_tensor_batch_to_uint8_clips_and_normalizes_channels():
rgba = torch.tensor([[[[1.5, -0.2, 0.5, 0.3]]]])
assert tc.tensor_batch_to_uint8(rgba).tolist() == [[[[255, 0, 127]]]]
gray = torch.full((1, 2, 2, 1), 0.5)
out = tc.tensor_batch_to_uint8(gray)
assert out.shape == (1, 2, 2, 3)
assert (out == 127).all()
def test_quality_to_crf_mapping():
assert tc.quality_to_crf(100, 51) == 0
assert tc.quality_to_crf(90, 51) == 13
assert tc.quality_to_crf(80, 51) == 19
assert tc.quality_to_crf(90, 63) == 16
assert tc.quality_to_crf(1, 51) == 51
assert tc.quality_to_crf("bogus", 51) == tc.quality_to_crf(tc.DEFAULT_TRANSFER_QUALITY, 51)
def test_normalize_format_rejects_unknown_values():
assert tc.normalize_format(" H264 ") == "h264"
assert tc.normalize_format(None) == tc.DEFAULT_TRANSFER_FORMAT
with pytest.raises(tc.TransferCodecError):
tc.normalize_format("gif")
def test_decode_chunk_validates_envelope_against_payload():
frames = tc.tensor_batch_to_uint8(_smooth_frames(count=2))
chunk = next(tc.encode_chunks(frames, "png", 90, 10**9))
envelope = {k: v for k, v in chunk.items() if k != "parts"}
with pytest.raises(tc.TransferCodecError, match="image parts"):
tc.decode_chunk({**envelope, "count": 3}, chunk["parts"])
with pytest.raises(tc.TransferCodecError, match="expected"):
tc.decode_chunk({**envelope, "width": 10}, chunk["parts"])
with pytest.raises(tc.TransferCodecError, match="count"):
tc.decode_chunk({**envelope, "count": 0}, chunk["parts"])
with pytest.raises(tc.TransferCodecError):
tc.decode_chunk(envelope, [b"not an image", b"nope"])
video = next(tc.encode_chunks(frames, "ffv1", 90, 10**9))
video_env = {k: v for k, v in video.items() if k != "parts"}
with pytest.raises(tc.TransferCodecError, match="frames"):
tc.decode_chunk({**video_env, "count": 5}, video["parts"])
def test_legacy_format_is_not_chunk_encoded():
frames = tc.tensor_batch_to_uint8(_smooth_frames(count=1))
with pytest.raises(tc.TransferCodecError):
list(tc.encode_chunks(frames, "legacy_png", 90, 10**9))
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------- #
# Size bounds on finalized payloads
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------- #
def _noise_frames(count=30, height=360, width=640, seed=97):
"""High-entropy frames: worst case for every codec, and enough encoder
lookahead that pre-flush buffer sizes badly underestimate final sizes."""
return np.random.default_rng(seed).integers(0, 256, size=(count, height, width, 3), dtype=np.uint8)
@pytest.mark.parametrize("fmt", ["h264", "ffv1"])
def test_video_chunks_are_bounded_after_encoder_flush(fmt):
frames = _noise_frames()
limit = 1024 * 1024
# Sanity: one unconstrained encode of this batch is far above the limit,
# so the bound below is actually being enforced.
unbounded = next(tc.encode_chunks(frames, fmt, 90, 10**12))
assert len(unbounded["parts"][0]) > 3 * limit
chunks = list(tc.encode_chunks(frames, fmt, 90, limit))
assert all(len(c["parts"]) == 1 and len(c["parts"][0]) <= limit for c in chunks)
assert [c["start_index"] for c in chunks] == list(np.cumsum([0] + [c["count"] for c in chunks[:-1]]))
assert sum(c["count"] for c in chunks) == len(frames)
decoded = [f for c in chunks for f in tc.decode_chunk(c, c["parts"])]
assert len(decoded) == len(frames)
if fmt == "ffv1":
assert np.array_equal(np.stack(decoded), frames)
def test_single_video_frame_may_exceed_chunk_target_up_to_frame_limit():
frames = _noise_frames(count=3)
one_frame = len(next(tc.encode_chunks(frames[:1], "ffv1", 90, 10**12))["parts"][0])
chunks = list(tc.encode_chunks(frames, "ffv1", 90, one_frame // 2, one_frame * 2))
assert [c["count"] for c in chunks] == [1, 1, 1]
assert all(one_frame // 2 < len(c["parts"][0]) <= one_frame * 2 for c in chunks)
@pytest.mark.parametrize("fmt", ["ffv1", "h264", "png"])
def test_frame_that_cannot_fit_alone_raises(fmt):
frames = _noise_frames(count=2)
with pytest.raises(tc.FrameTooLargeError, match="request limit"):
list(tc.encode_chunks(frames, fmt, 90, 64 * 1024, 64 * 1024))
def test_still_chunks_are_bounded():
frames = _noise_frames(count=10)
limit = 1024 * 1024
chunks = list(tc.encode_chunks(frames, "jpeg", 90, limit))
assert all(sum(len(p) for p in c["parts"]) <= limit for c in chunks)
assert sum(c["count"] for c in chunks) == 10